Unmet Expectations in Relationships: Why Am I So Disappointed?

“I was waiting the whole night for you to come to me,” she said with a steely, sleep deprived alertness.

They had had another fight. Same repetitive topic. It did not need to be a big thing, she said.

It was just that it kept happening. Something little. Maybe inconsiderate. Maybe he did not acknowledge her feelings. And his so-called repair, when it finally came, didn’t really land.

They had been apart for two and a half weeks, both traveling for work, both looking forward to being reunited. But the homecoming had been chaotic. Kids, groceries, unpacking, dinner, a guinea pig out of her cage. There had not really been a moment for them.

Finally they were alone.

And one of the first things he told her was that he was thinking of spending the following night in their cabin in the mountains.

It was not a terrible thing. He was not abandoning her. He wanted to be alone. It hurt.

They argued. She tried to explain why. He accused her of therapizing him. It became clear that whatever conversation she was trying to have was not going to happen.

He got up to leave the bed. She asked him not to.

Then he asked, “Can I hold you?” His touch felt scratchy to her. She did not feel consoled. His body felt foreign. It was uncomfortable. After about thirty minutes she slipped out of bed and moved to the couch.

She was half awake all night with a knot in her stomach. She wished to be sought. The thing that kept her awake was the feeling that if he cared, he would come. That he would make the efforts she would make. That the disconnection would bother him enough to get out of bed and find her. That his need for harmony between them would somehow equal hers.

And somewhere during those hours, the original hurt became something much bigger. There are certain moments we have already lived in our imagination before they ever happen: a birthday, an anniversary, the first night of a vacation, a reunion after being apart…

Many of the expectations that hurt us most are only partially conscious. We may not even know that we are carrying them. We only discover them when the moment arrives and something feels wrong. Maybe we imagined being chosen: some unmistakable recognition that this moment mattered to the other person too.

Then reality shows up with phones ringing, laundry, jet lag.

And what happened is suddenly being compared with what we thought was going to happen. Sometimes the disappointment is obvious. Someone forgot your birthday. Someone broke a promise. Someone said something cruel. Other times nobody did anything “terrible.”

And yet somehow we feel gutted. Why am I this upset? Are my expectations unreasonable?

The problem is often what we start making the disappointment mean.

She did not simply lie on the couch thinking, I wish he would come. It became, If he cared, he would come. Then, I would come after him. Then, Maybe I care more. And from there it is a very short distance to, What does this say about us?

The expectation has turned into evidence. We take what love would make us do and turn it into a test of somebody else's love.

If I missed you, I would want to spend the first night together. If I hurt you, I would come after you. If I knew you were lying awake on the couch, I could not just stay in bed. If I cared the way you say you care, I would see it in your behavior.

Relationships are made of behavior. Love fails us if it never becomes something lived between two people. But there is also something dangerous about the speed with which we move from this is what I needed to if you loved me, this is what you would have done.

Expectations do not end when the disappointing moment is over. We also carry expectations about repair. How quickly should you notice that something is wrong? Should you come after me? Should you apologize before I ask? Should the disconnection bother you as much as it bothers me? Should your attempt to repair somehow match the size of the pain I am feeling?

So now there are two disappointments: This was not the homecoming I imagined. And then: This is not the repair I imagined either.

The second disappointment can make the first one feel even bigger. 

If I am always the one noticing, explaining, returning, softening, asking, and repairing, eventually the problem is not simply that my expectations are too high. There may actually be an asymmetry in how much relational work we are each willing to do. But one missed expectation does not automatically tell us what we think it tells us.

The next morning, he came to her on the couch with coffee. He had been awake too. They talked again. They went around in circles for a while, and then something shifted. He told her that when he had seen her the day before, after those weeks apart, he had thought, Wow. I am so lucky. This is my wife. She stared at him. “Why didn’t you tell me that?”

All night she had been making meaning out of what he had shown her. He had come home and almost immediately talked about leaving again. He had not come to find her on the couch. His attempt at repair had not reached her. She saw him as giving up. From that, she had concluded that he had not cared about the reunion.

But there had been something she couldn’t see. He had looked at her and felt lucky. He had simply kept that experience inside himself. And in the absence of what he felt, she had been left to interpret what he did.

Someone can love us and still fail to deliver that love in the form we were waiting for. They can feel lucky to have us and forget to say it. They can miss us and still want an evening alone. 

None of this means we should lower every expectation or teach ourselves to accept whatever someone gives. Sometimes disappointment is showing us exactly what is missing.

But before we turn it into a fact, it is worth becoming curious about the expectation itself: What had I imagined this moment would feel like? Did I even know I was expecting that? What did I make it mean when it did not happen? 

She had spent the night believing that she had not been wanted enough. He had come home thinking he was lucky she was his wife.

Both things existed in the same relationship on the same night.

Learn more about my approach here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here.

Next
Next

What’s Wrong With You?