When Their Story Never Changes: The Trap of Righteous Venting

The Friend Who Keeps Telling the Same Story

Her marriage was falling apart. She needed someone. At first, it felt like being a good friend. She was hurting, and I could hold space. I knew the backstory. I cared. She came to me, again and again. I thought I was helping. I really did.

But something didn’t feel right.

Each time she came, it was the same story. Different details, same frame: he was cruel. She was righteous. She had no part in it. She just needed someone to see it.

No curiosity. No insight. Just different versions of the same grievance, again and again. And it wasn’t a conversation, it was a monologue. There was no room for me.

Just a download. A vent. A long emotional release that came with an unspoken demand: hold this for me. Make it okay. Validate me. Make it his fault.

I tried to reflect. I tried to stay generous. But I started feeling… tired. Depleted. Hijacked.

And then I realized: this isn’t a dialogue. It’s a performance.

And underneath it all, I felt trapped.

We’ve All Had a Friend Like This

The one who calls, unloads, and doesn’t ask how you are.

The one who says they want clarity but only listens for confirmation.

The one who says, “I just need to vent,” but vents with such force and frequency that it becomes emotional trespassing.

Why is it so confusing?

Because they’re suffering.

Because you care.

Because we’re told (especially as women) that being a good friend means being there.

But what happens when being there becomes being used?

What’s Actually Going On

What’s happening underneath isn’t always obvious, but there’s a structure to it.

They’re not asking for help, they’re seeking confirmation. They’re not in reflection, they’re in rumination. They’re not vulnerable, they’re self-protecting through blame.

It feels like intimacy. But it’s actually control.

And when you start looking more closely, the pattern often includes:

• Righteous victimhood: A need to maintain moral clarity by externalizing all fault. It offers safety, but prevents growth.

• Non-mutual use of intimacy: One person shares emotionally to create a bond they have no intention of reciprocating. It feels close, but isn’t.

• Unconscious guilt-leveraging: Their pain becomes your obligation. If you pull back, you’re “abandoning” them.

• Refusal of feedback: Any input that challenges the narrative gets blocked or reframed as betrayal.

• Emotional outsourcing: You become the container for feelings they won’t metabolize themselves.

It’s not intentional. But it’s still exhausting. And over time, it erodes the foundation of friendship.

Memory Hardening

Each retelling of the story—without new insight, context, or emotional movement—makes it worse.

Not just emotionally. Neurologically.

The neuroscience is clear: every time we recall a memory, we open a small window where it becomes malleable. That’s the principle behind memory reconsolidation.

If you revisit an old story while feeling new insight, new safety, or new regulation, the memory can soften. It changes shape.

But if you revisit it and flood your system with the same anger, blame, or despair: you don’t soften it. You harden it.

You rewire your nervous system to believe the story even more.

You calcify it.

You turn the memory into identity.

This is the opposite of healing. This is memory hardening.

Why It’s So Draining

You feel trapped: if you don’t respond, you’re cold. If you do respond, you’re reinforcing the loop.

Your energy goes into protecting their worldview, not supporting change.

You become the guilt-receiver. The secret therapist. The resentment sponge.

And here’s the real heartbreak:

You’re not helping them.

Signs You’re in the Dump-Loop

• You dread seeing their name on your phone.

• You feel responsible for their emotional regulation.

• You rehearse your responses to avoid backlash.

• You feel more tired after every “supportive” conversation.

• They say they want insight but reject every reflection.

Why They Stay Stuck

They confuse venting with processing.

They confuse certainty with safety.

They confuse blame with healing.

They don’t actually want help, they want righteousness without risk.

And they often can’t admit: I’m scared. I don’t want to look at my part. If I let go of this story, who will I be?

The Non-Mutual Use of Intimacy

This is what makes it feel so confusing.

They seem raw. Emotional. In need.

But the intimacy is one-way.

They cry, you listen. They rage, you contain. They monologue, you hold space.

You become a container for their projection. Not a friend, not an equal. A backdrop to their pain.

You weren’t asked. You were cast.

This Is Not Friendship

Friendship is mutual. It’s reflective. It makes space for truth.

What’s being asked of you in these loops isn’t connection. It’s containment.

And the longer you keep absorbing it, the less of you there is in the room.

Are you interested in working on your personal development? Are you looking for a life coach or a life consultant? Are you feeling stagnant? Do you want to jumpstart change?

 My transformational approach is a process where awareness, alignment, and action work together as catalysts to create momentum for change. 

*Awareness is knowing what you genuinely want and need.

*Alignment is the symmetry between our values and our actions. It means our inner and outer worlds match.

*Action is when you are conscious that what you say, do and think are in harmony with your values.

Together we build an understanding of what you want to accomplish, and delve deeply into building awareness around any thoughts and assumptions that you may already have. To truly transform your life, I will empower you to rethink what’s possible for you.

__

Learn more about my approach to life consulting and relationship coaching here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here! Don’t forget to follow along @LilyManne on social for more regular updates!