Scarcity and the Nervous System: When Enough Never Feels Safe

Some people feel safer with nothing.

It doesn’t look that way at first. They might complain about money, about stress, about never having enough. They might say they want ease. Stability.  But watch closely, and you’ll start to see something else: the moment they have a little breathing room, they panic. They offload it. They stay maxed out—financially, emotionally, logistically. Because the discomfort of having feels worse than the discomfort of not having.

To have something: money, time, rest, love—means you could lose it. It introduces risk. Exposure. Vulnerability. It brings up questions about responsibility, about worthiness, about what happens next. And for some nervous systems, that is too much.

So the coping mechanism kicks in.

People often think of scarcity as an external condition: not enough money or time. But in reality, scarcity is a felt experience. You can feel poor in any domain—emotionally, relationally, energetically—and respond as if you’re in crisis, even when you’re not. It’s not about the actual number in the bank account. It’s about the nervous system’s interpretation: this isn’t safe. I can’t hold this. Get rid of it before something goes wrong.

And once that signal fires, the urgency comes.

The loop looks like this:
Discomfort → Urgency → Action → Relief → Consequence → Shame → Discomfort

It feels like action. But it’s actually avoidance.

That’s what makes scarcity so tricky: it masquerades as agency. The actions—spending, rushing, fixing, saying yes, saying no, avoiding stillness, overcommitting—feel like control. But they’re not strategy. They’re reflex. A protective loop.

And it works. At least in the short term.

Because it offloads discomfort. That internal pressure of having something and not knowing what to do with it. That unbearable sense of being at risk simply by being resourced.

But that relief doesn’t last. It resets the whole system back to scarcity. Back to threat. And the cycle begins again.

Coping Mechanism, Not Character Flaw

People aren’t doing this because they’re irresponsible or impulsive. They’re doing it because at some earlier point (often in childhood) this pattern was adaptive. Being empty meant being safe. Having nothing meant nothing could be taken away. Depleting oneself was a form of self-protection.

It becomes a strategy for managing fear. And the strategy sticks, even long after it stops being useful.

This is what we mean in therapy when we say a coping mechanism is no longer adaptive. It helped once. But now it’s keeping you in a loop. It's not supporting your capacity, it’s undermining it.

What the Research Shows

Scarcity doesn’t just shape our choices, it alters how our brain functions.

Behavioral economists Sendhil Mullainathan and Eldar Shafir have shown that scarcity actually reduces cognitive bandwidth. Their studies reveal that when people feel they don’t have enough—whether it’s money, food, or time—their brains enter a kind of tunnel vision. They hyper-focus on the immediate need and lose access to long-term planning, self-regulation, and memory.

It’s not because they don’t care about the future. It’s because the nervous system is triaging the present.

As they write, “Scarcity captures the mind. The mind orients automatically, powerfully, toward unfulfilled needs.” And when that happens, everything else drops out of view.

This helps explain why people in a scarcity state often make decisions that seem irrational from the outside. The brain simply isn’t operating with its full capacity. Shah, Mullainathan, and Shafir call this tunneling. What’s urgent dominates. What’s wise fades.

And what’s most dangerous? This scarcity state is self-reinforcing.
The very actions we take to relieve the pressure—spending impulsively, saying yes to everything, shutting down connection—create the conditions for more scarcity. And the loop tightens.

And it’s not just about money.

The same pattern plays out with love.

Some people feel safer emotionally depleted than emotionally met. It doesn’t matter how much love they’re offered, if their nervous system is wired for scarcity, it won’t register as nourishment. It won’t feel real. Or safe. Or enough.

Their partner may be kind, consistent, even expressive. But it still feels like something’s missing. And from inside that experience, the conclusion seems obvious: they must not be giving me enough.

But often, it’s not about what’s being given. It’s about what the nervous system can receive.

If you grew up with a parent who withheld love—who didn’t attune, didn’t soften, didn’t really see you—then that becomes your blueprint. You learn to live with hunger. You organize around the absence. And when love finally comes, your body doesn’t recognize it as nourishment. It’s undigestible: it slips right through. The body doesn’t trust it.

Or maybe you had a parent who overgave: who made love about sacrifice, depletion, martyrdom. You learned that love must cost something. That it comes through suffering. That someone has to lose for you to feel chosen. So when love comes without exhaustion, without drama, it doesn’t feel real. It feels suspicious. Weightless. Too easy. And you internalize a rule: if no one’s suffering, it must not be love.

Or maybe it’s even more confusing: one parent overgives, the other disappears. Love becomes a tightrope between extremes: too much and not enough. The result is the same: you never feel full. You don’t trust the middle. You long for something steady, but only recognize the shape of chaos.

This is emotional scarcity.

Only this time, the currency isn’t money. It’s love. Attention. Belonging. Presence. And the same drive to relieve pain through familiar behaviors, even when those behaviors make things worse.

People stuck in emotional scarcity often:

• Overfunction in relationships—doing all the emotional labor, holding the pulse of the dynamic

• Overgive: believing love must be earned, not received

• Only trust love that comes through effort, intensity, suffering, or sacrifice

• Test their partner constantly: pulling back to see if the other will follow, withdrawing, escalating, waiting to be chased

• Feel perpetually unseen, even when their partner is showing up

• Dismiss or downplay affection unless it’s dramatic, costly, or accompanied by struggle

• Withdraw preemptively: choosing emptiness over the risk of disappointment

• Collapse or explode in moments of emotional stillness

• Criticize or resent partners for not being “enough,” without realizing the bar is impossible
  

It's not that they’re ungrateful or manipulative. It’s that their entire system was built around surviving without enough. Now, they don’t know how to stay present with plenty.

Most people in this loop genuinely believe their partner isn’t loving them the right way. They scan for evidence of absence. They measure love in sacrifice and intensity, not steadiness or ease. They don’t realize that their body is rejecting the very thing they’re craving.

And that’s the heartbreak of emotional scarcity:
You can be surrounded by love and still feel alone.
You can be chosen again and again and still feel abandoned.
You can have everything you once longed for and feel like it’s not enough.

And the way through isn’t more giving. It’s more capacity.

The capacity to sit with love when it comes.
To stay when it’s quiet.
To believe something can feel good and still be safe.
To stop measuring love by how much it hurts.

This isn’t mindset work. It’s nervous system work.
And it starts by asking:
What would it mean to stop chasing, and start receiving?

Are you interested in working on your personal development? Are you looking for a life coach or a life consultant? Are you feeling stagnant? Do you want to jumpstart change?

 My transformational approach is a process where awareness, alignment, and action work together as catalysts to create momentum for change. 

*Awareness is knowing what you genuinely want and need.

*Alignment is the symmetry between our values and our actions. It means our inner and outer worlds match.

*Action is when you are conscious that what you say, do and think are in harmony with your values.

Together we build an understanding of what you want to accomplish, and delve deeply into building awareness around any thoughts and assumptions that you may already have. To truly transform your life, I will empower you to rethink what’s possible for you.

__

Learn more about my approach to life consulting and relationship coaching here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here! Don’t forget to follow along @LilyManne on social for more regular updates!