Transactional Love: The Hidden Cost to Trust and Intimacy

Most relationships start with love freely given. In the beginning, you don’t think about whether your efforts will be matched—you just give. You show up, you listen, you plan surprises, you touch them in passing, you reach for them at night. Not because you’re tracking who did what, but because it feels good to give.

And then, slowly, something shifts.

Maybe one partner starts feeling like they’re pulling more weight. Maybe someone gets hurt and quietly withholds. Maybe a disappointment lingers longer than it should. And without realizing it, a ledger forms.

Now, love is no longer just an offering: it’s an exchange.

One partner starts thinking: I planned the last three date nights, why can’t they take the initiative for once? I always check in first, why don’t they ever reach out to me? I’ve been more affectionate, why don’t they match that energy?

It’s human. We all do it. It’s hard to shake the feeling that effort should be reciprocated, that fairness matters, that we shouldn’t be the only ones trying. And there’s truth in that: relationships shouldn’t be one-sided.

But when love becomes entirely transactional, something essential begins to erode.

If every act of care comes with an unspoken expectation, if every gesture is weighed against what came before, the relationship stops being about trust. It stops being a safe place to land.

Instead, it becomes a quiet negotiation.

One partner waits for proof of love before offering their own. The other feels the pressure of meeting an invisible quota. Every touch, every act of kindness, every moment of patience: if it isn’t returned in equal measure, resentment builds.

No one feels safe in this dynamic.

The person keeping the ledger feels unappreciated, unseen, like they’re giving more than they’re getting. The person on the other side feels measured and tested rather than loved.

It’s not that fairness doesn’t matter. It does. But fairness isn’t the foundation of love, trust is.

Real trust is giving without the guarantee of return. Trust doesn’t get tested. It’s a leap of faith.

Not in a way that erases your needs. Not in a way that turns you into a martyr. But in a way that recognizes love is not a perfectly balanced equation. There will be moments when you give more, when you hold more, when you carry the weight of the relationship. And moments when they do.

But if you only give when you’re sure you’ll get something back, if you hold back love as a way of testing or protecting yourself: then neither of you ever really lands.

Love is not a debt. And the second it starts feeling like one, the trust that holds the whole thing together begins to crack.

Are you looking for help with your relationship? Do you feel that a relationship coach could help you working on your couples skills? Is communication an issue? Have you ever considered couples therapy or counseling? As a psychotherapist and relationship coach, I am uniquely positioned to help you through these moments of disconnect and conflict.

__

Learn more about my approach to life consulting and relationship coaching here or get in touch for your free 30-minute consultation here! Don’t forget to follow along @LilyManne on social for more regular updates!